Get your FREE months when you start today * Terms apply

Get your FREE months when you start today * Terms apply

Get your FREE months when you start today * Terms apply

Get your FREE months when you start today * Terms apply

Get your FREE months when you start today * Terms apply

Get your FREE months when you start today * Terms apply

Get your FREE months when you start today * Terms apply

Get your FREE months when you start today * Terms apply

SurePayroll vs. Gusto

SurePayroll is purpose-built for small businesses with 1–5 employees. Gusto is a full HR platform built for larger teams.

If you're not starting with 20 people, you're paying for a platform that is

SurePayroll
Price
SurePayroll is priced for businesses with 1–5 employees.
SurePayroll starts at $36/month for one employee.
Gusto is priced for larger teams.
Gusto starts at $55/month. For a business with three employees, that's a meaningful difference — every month, all year.
Focus
SurePayroll is built around the features small businesses need.
SurePayroll is payroll and tax filing, built for 1–5 employees — not scaled down from something bigger.
Gusto includes features most small businesses may never use.
Gusto includes hiring tools, PTO tracking, and benefits administration. Those are real features — for a business with 20+ employees. If you have three, you're paying for a platform built for someone else's headcount.
Support
SurePayroll includes free account setup and payroll migration for every customer.
When you sign up for SurePayroll, a dedicated setup team is available to walk you through the process — no matter how many employees you have.
Setup and migration support only available on highest tier plan.
With Gusto, payroll migration and account setup is a premium feature — not included on Simple or Plus plans.

Payroll built for your business — not someone else's headcount.

SurePayroll is purpose-built for solopreneurs and small businesses with 1–5 employees. Set up in minutes. Supported from day one.

Trusted by small business owners across the U.S.

25+ years
Serving small businesses
4.4 / 5
Rated on G2
A+
Better Business Bureau