Get your FREE months when you start today * Terms apply

Get your FREE months when you start today * Terms apply

Get your FREE months when you start today * Terms apply

Get your FREE months when you start today * Terms apply

Get your FREE months when you start today * Terms apply

Get your FREE months when you start today * Terms apply

Get your FREE months when you start today * Terms apply

Get your FREE months when you start today * Terms apply

SurePayroll vs. OnPay

SurePayroll is built with AutoPayroll — payroll that moves on your schedule without requiring a manual run every pay period. OnPay requires manual submission.

SurePayroll is built for owners on the go

SurePayroll
AutoPayroll
Keep payroll moving on your schedule.
With SurePayroll, AutoPayroll is ready to go before you need it — set it up once, and under 5 minutes to adjust if something changes.
OnPay requires a manual run every pay period.
OnPay requires you to log in, review, and submit every pay period. It works — but it's on your to-do list every time.
Price
SurePayroll is priced lower for small businesses with 1–5 employees.
SurePayroll starts at $36/month for one employee.
OnPay starts at $55/month.
For a business with three employees, that's a meaningful difference — every month, all year.
Direct Deposit
SurePayroll offers 2-day direct deposit standard from the first payroll.
Two-day direct deposit is included with SurePayroll from day one — no waiting period, no conditions.
OnPay's direct deposit timeline varies by customer.
OnPay determines direct deposit timing after signup, and turnaround can range from 2 to 4 days.

Built for owners on the go — not tied to a desk.

SurePayroll is purpose-built for solopreneurs and small businesses with 1–5 employees. AutoPayroll, straightforward pricing, and 2-day direct deposit standard — from day one.

Trusted by small business owners across the U.S.

25+ years
Serving small businesses
4.4 / 5
Rated on G2
A+
Better Business Bureau