A payroll spreadsheet can work for a small dental practice until every payday starts requiring another manual calculation, handoff or check. You don't have to wait until year-end to move that process into payroll software. Choose the first payroll you want to run in the new system, bring over complete year-to-date payroll information and verify the first run before leaving the spreadsheet behind.
If you're moving midyear, the payroll you've already run matters as much as the payroll ahead. SurePayroll® By Paychex helps you upload it when you set up your account.
When manual payroll becomes harder to control in a dental practice
Manual payroll processing gets harder to control when each pay period depends on more figures that you calculate, carry forward and recheck by hand. Production pay makes that visible: you pull the production total, calculate the pay and account for its effect on overtime when required. If a production figure changes after a correction, the numbers downstream may change too.
Add more providers, another location or an off-cycle correction, and that manual chain gets longer. From one pay run to the next, more of your payroll time goes to re-entering and reconciling figures than to running payroll.
When manual payroll reaches that point, look at what's creating the extra work and use it to define what you need from payroll software.
SurePayroll calculates and files payroll taxes for practices running mixed pay structures: employees who receive W-2s, contractors who receive 1099-NECs from one dashboard.
What payroll software needs to handle for a dental practice
Payroll software doesn't have to be built for dental practices. It has to work with the ways you pay your team, from production-based compensation and hourly wages to your own S-corp salary. Start with the pay arrangements you're managing manually today, then check whether the software can support and automate the calculations for each one. Once you know what you need, these questions can help you compare specific systems.
Pay particular attention to compensation that affects other payroll calculations. For example, production-based compensation can affect overtime calculations for a non-exempt employee. Make sure the software supports the way you pay that employee. See the dental payroll guide for more information.
With SurePayroll, you enter the production amount each pay period, and SurePayroll applies the correct withholding and tax treatment from there.
Decide how much of the tax work you want the payroll provider to take on, too. Some payroll services deposit and file payroll taxes for you, while pay-only options leave those tasks with you. That choice matters during the switch and after it.
You'll also need to set up any elected deductions and active garnishments for the employees they apply to.
Payroll software and practice management software
Your practice management software, such as Dentrix, Eaglesoft or Open Dental, tracks the production figures you use to calculate pay. Payroll software does a different job, payroll processing: calculating pay, withholding and payroll taxes from the payroll information you provide. That creates a handoff each pay period. Someone needs to pull the production report for the right dates, confirm the figures and enter them in payroll before you run it. Decide who owns that step, and by when, before your first software payroll run.
When to switch a dental practice from manual payroll to payroll software
You can switch to payroll software at any time of year. Start by choosing the first payday you want to run in the new system. Then ask the provider how much time you'll need for setup and authorization, and schedule your last manual payroll around that go-live date.
Starting at the beginning of a quarter or year means less payroll history within the current reporting period to bring over. But you don't have to wait. If you switch mid-quarter, make sure the new system has complete year-to-date payroll information and confirm who is responsible for deposits and filings during the transition.
The same timing considerations apply when switching payroll providers.
What to prepare before moving your practice's payroll into software
Before your first payroll run in the new system, gather the information it needs for the data migration: your business, your team and the payroll you've already run this year.
- Business accounts: Have your employer identification number (EIN), state withholding and unemployment account information, and your state-assigned unemployment tax rate ready.
- Your team: Gather IRS Forms W-4, Employee's Withholding Certificate, and applicable state withholding forms, along with pay rates and pay types, deductions and garnishments, and direct deposit bank account information. For contractors, you'll need IRS Form W-9, Request for Taxpayer Identification Number and Certification. Document how each provider is paid, including any production arrangement, and confirm an associate's employee or contractor classification before adding them to payroll.
- Year-to-date payroll: Gather wages and withholding for everyone you've paid this year, including former employees. Include production pay and bonuses in each employee's wage totals, your own salary, contractor payments, Forms 941, Employer's Quarterly Federal Tax Return, and the payroll tax deposits you've already made.
Before entering year-to-date totals, reconcile your spreadsheet with your payroll tax filings and deposits, ideally with your accountant. The guide to moving from manual payroll to payroll software explains that reconciliation process.
"[My rep] was extremely nice and helpful with getting my payroll setup. It was nice to talk to someone that seemed to really care about what they were doing and helping a small business owner like myself. It is rough to find that nowadays."
— Katie S., Better Business Bureau review
Year-to-date totals and the Social Security wage base
Social Security tax withholding stops once the wages you've paid an employee during the calendar year reach the wage base: $184,500 for 2026 and $192,300 for 2027. Additional Medicare Tax withholding starts in the pay period when the wages you've paid that employee for the year exceed $200,000, regardless of filing status.
If an associate or your owner-dentist salary is near or past either threshold, complete year-to-date wages are especially important when you switch payroll systems. The new system needs the wages your practice has already paid that person this year to know when each withholding rule applies.
How to move your dental practice payroll into payroll software
Once your records are ready, set a clear last manual payroll and a go-live date for your first software payroll, with time in between to complete setup and verify the new system.
If your payroll provider will make federal tax deposits and file returns on your behalf, you'll authorize it to do so with Form 8655, Reporting Agent Authorization. That authorization applies to the periods specified on the form; you remain responsible for your employment taxes. The guide to moving from manual payroll to payroll software explains the authorization.
When you verify, check the pay that's hardest to get right by hand. For example, compare the software's calculation for a hygienist with production-based pay and overtime with the amount you expected before you approve the payroll. Trace any meaningful difference rather than assuming the new calculation is correct. Then confirm your team's direct deposit information and show employees where to find their pay stubs.
Payroll tax deposits and filings during the switch
If your payroll provider will make tax deposits and file returns for you, confirm which deposits and returns you will handle during the transition and when the provider takes over. If your software calculates payroll taxes but doesn't deposit or file them for you, you remain responsible for making the deposits and filing the returns.
- Deposits for your manual payrolls: each deposit's due date depends on when you paid the wages and on your federal deposit schedule, so the deposit for your last manual payroll can come due after the switch. Confirm whether you or your provider will make it.
- Returns for periods before the authorization begins are yours to file.
- For the quarter you switch, Form 941 reports the wages you paid for the full quarter, including payroll you ran manually before the switch. Confirm with your provider who will file the return and how your earlier payroll will be included.
- Year-end Forms W-2 report each employee's wages for the full year.
- Confirm separately who will handle any required state filings during the transition.
Watch for two gaps during the switch: a required deposit that neither you nor the provider makes, or a deposit or return that both of you submit.
Run your dental practice payroll with SurePayroll
With SurePayroll, you pay employees and contractors from one account, and SurePayroll deposits payroll taxes on your assigned schedule and files your returns.
This content is for educational purposes only, is not intended to provide specific legal advice, and should not be used as a substitute for the legal advice of a qualified attorney or other professional. The information may not reflect the most current legal developments, may be changed without notice and is not guaranteed to be complete, correct, or up to date








